Sunday, May 29, 2022
Smart Phones

Google’s Pixel 3 XL notch ‘fix’ is dumb and you should just buy a regular Pixel 3 instead

The Pixel 3 XL hasn’t even gone on sale yet and a lot of words have been written about the notch. I know, because I’ve written many of them. The controversy over the Pixel 3 XL’s extra-large notch will surely rage on for weeks to come, at least until the next tech tumult takes hold of our attention.

In response to the outcry, Google has offered a solution. Sort of. In a tweet from the Made by Google account, the company confirmed that there will be an option to hide the display cutout on the Pixel 3 XL for those who prefer “a more traditional smartphone look.” Or, you know, one that’s not ugly as hell.

Like the LG V40, OnePlus 6, and other notchy phones, the solution is to put a black bar across the top so the notch blends in with the screen next to it. It’s an inelegant solution on most handsets, creating an unbalanced forehead and chin and taking away what should be a distinguishing characteristic. The best blackout bars leave the status bar icons at the top of the screen so the screen remaining below the notch isn’t truncated at all, but because they’re software based, none of them look as good as a static black bezel.

As it stands, Google’s solution doesn’t do that. For one, the notch is way deep, so the bar is deeper than the usual status bar. For another, it pushes the status bar below the notch so you’re losing even more useable space.

notch hide pixel 3xlMichael Simon/IDG

Hiding the Pixel 3 XL’s notch makes the phone worse.

Now, things might change if and when Google pushes the solution to Android proper. As it stands, the option is part of Android Developer Options, and it’s not exactly easy to find:

  1. Go to the Settings app
  2. Scroll down to System
  3. Tap About phone
  4. Find Build number at the bottom the screen
  5. Tap Build number seven times
  6. Enter your passcode
  7. Go back to the main System screen
  8. Tap Advanced
  9. Select the new Developer options tab
  10. Scroll down to the Drawing section
  11. Tap Display cutout
  12. Tap Hide

Easy right? Now, Google will presumably by adding this option to the main Display settings tab at some point, but for now, it’s a band-aid and not one of those cool Avengers ones either. Even if Google does design the notch-hiding option to include the status bar, it’s still going to look weird and ugly due to the shape of the cutout.

So here’s my advice. Either buy a Pixel 3 XL and deal with the notch or get a Pixel 3 instead. Yes, you’re getting less screen (5.5 inches versus 6.3 inches), but you won’t have to look at the notch, you’ll still get the newest Pixel with the newest specs, and you won’t be giving up any of the new camera or AI features. And you’ll save $100 to boot.

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.


Leave a Reply

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.